In one of his memoirs, the actor Charles Grodin tells the
story of being on the set of a movie with Candice Bergen. As the cameras were
being set up in the main hall of a castle outside of London, he and Bergen were
sitting together in an adjacent room.
Shortly after that sat, an Englishwoman appeared, Grodin
writes. "She said, 'Did someone ask you to wait in here?' 'No,' we
answered, a bit taken aback. She responded: 'Well, it would be so nice if you
weren't here.'"
While a proper Englishwoman is not the bearer of the
message, it seems that "You're not invited" messages are increasingly
sent to friends or relatives who have not made the list of invitees to an
upcoming wedding. I've yet to receive one myself, since my friends have the
good graces to simply not invite me when they would prefer me not to be at
their special day.
But event planners or the couples themselves have
increasingly been deciding that rather than simply battling out a list of
invitees and sending invitations to those who made the cut, they want to send a
little something special to their friends and relatives who didn't pass muster.
Rina Raphael, a writer for Today.com also reported
"variations of this trend," where some couples tell friends that
they're on "the B list." If a preferred guest dings the couple on
their invite, the friends on the B list are told they'll be in.
It used to be de rigueur -- and presumably still is in
many circles -- to send wedding announcements after the wedding had occurred to
let folks who hadn't been invited know you'd tied the knot. But the practice of
alerting people ahead of time to something they're not going to be getting that
they didn't ask to get in the first place appears to be new.
So is it the right thing to notify people about something
they're not going to be invited to when you know that there's a good chance
you'll hurt them more than if you simply didn't invite them?
Sometimes being overly forthcoming can clearly be cruel.
A doctor must decide, for example, just how much clinical detail to provide
when talking to a dying patient. Sissela Bok, the author of Lying: MoralChoice in Public and Private Life (Vintage Books, 1989), once told me:
"There's great room for discretion, for knowing when not to speak."
Not netting an invitation to the wedding of the season
and being informed you're dying are hardly synonymous. But the non-invitation
invitation raises the question of whether deliberately doing something that is
likely to exacerbate hurt feelings is the way we want to choose to behave with
our friends.
Obviously, it's the bride's and groom's choice. But if
they truly want to take the feelings of their non-invited friends into account,
there's no valor in rubbing salt in the wounds. The friends may be hurt enough
once they learn they haven't been invited. The right thing to do if you don't
plan to invite someone to a wedding is to simply not invite them.
Jeffrey L. Seglin, author of
The Right Thing: Conscience, Profit and Personal Responsibility in Today's Business and
The Good, the Bad, and Your Business: Choosing Right When
Ethical Dilemmas Pull You Apart, is a lecturer in public
policy and director of the communications program at Harvard's Kennedy
School.
Follow him on Twitter:
@jseglin
(c) 2013 JEFFREY L. SEGLIN. Distributed by Tribune MediaServices, Inc.
2 comments:
While it may seem crass, it certainly clears up the question as to whether the invitation was lost. So it seems like a good idea.
And the non invitee may be relieved that he doesn't need to think about attending and a gift.
Alan Owseichik
Greenfield, Ma
My God, Jeffrey. Are you serious?!? Sending non-invites to family, friends or even acquaintances is the height of tactlessness! What would someone think they gain by sending such uninvites?!? Sending a notice, especially before the wedding, without invitation smacks of attempt to guilt people into sending gifts.
While this sounds much more a question of etiquette than ethics, I can not see any reason to behave in such a manner unless the purpose is to burn bridges with everyone such a notice is sent to.
William Jacobson
Anaheim, CA
Post a Comment