Is it OK to take glee in wanting someone who made the same mistake as you did to get caught?
Several decades ago when my parents were still alive and living in Williamsburg, Virginia, the woman I’d eat bees for and I decided to make the drive from Boston to Williamsburg to pay a visit. We decided to break up the trip by stopping overnight in Washington, D.C., to visit some friends and to explore some of the many museums there.
One evening we were driving through Georgetown to meet our friends. I was driving. I approached a stoplight that was turning yellow and soon to turn red. Instead of slowing down and stopping, I proceeded through the yellow light and took a right turn onto a side street. I was greeted by a police offer waving me to pull over next to another car that had apparently already been pulled over for running the light.
As the officer approached my window, I rolled it down, and she began by asking if I knew I had run a red light. Before I could even consider deciding whether to acknowledge the truth or come up with some lame excuse, the driver in a car that had already been pulled over shouted over to her: “Give him a ticket too.”
The officer broke off her conversation with me, looked over the top of my car at the gentleman in the other car, and then waved me on with what I recall was an exaggerated wave of her hand and simply told me: “You can go on.”
My assumption has always been that had the other guy not shouted out at her, I too would have received a citation for running the light. Was she right to give me a pass on my infraction? Probably not. I was wrong and deserved a ticket. Did I argue with her? No.
Certainly, the other driver was upset that he had been pulled over and ticketed. I would have been too. But that he felt the need to vocally make sure that others were punished simply because he had been wouldn’t have made his ticket any less expensive. Sure, the fair thing would have been for me to be treated as he had been and I likely would have been had he let the officer do her job.
That incident from back in the mid-1980s has stuck with me all these years. It reinforced a sense that each of us should try to take responsibility for our own actions rather than make sure everyone goes down with us. Did I know whether his infraction was greater than mine? No. Could the officer simply have decided that a warning for me running the yellow light was enough? Sure. Perhaps she was simply showing me kindness rather than reacting to the berating she received from the other driver.
That incident also made me more careful at stop lights while driving, not just in Georgetown, but anywhere. I’ve not been stopped for running a light since. But if I am, the right thing would be to acknowledge my error, pay my fine and move on.
Jeffrey L. Seglin, author of The Simple Art of Business Etiquette: How to Rise to the Top by Playing Nice, is a senior lecturer in public policy and director of the communications program at Harvard's Kennedy School. He is also the administrator of www.jeffreyseglin.com, a blog focused on ethical issues.
Do you have ethical questions that you need to have answered? Send them to jeffreyseglin@gmail.com.
Follow him on Twitter @jseglin.
(c) 2024 JEFFREY L. SEGLIN. Distributed by TRIBUNE CONTENT AGENCY, LLC.
No comments:
Post a Comment